The key chart
The key message
The rise in COVID-19 cases and the discovery of the new Omicron variant come at a delicate and unfortunate time for the UK economic recovery (and associated recovery trades).
According to the Bank of England’s latest “Money and Credit” release for October 2021, monthly household money flows were moderating and demand for consumer credit was recovering at the start of 4Q21 – positive trends in two of our three key signals for 2021. So called “faster indicators” such as credit and debit card payments also indicate that positive trends continued into mid-November 2021.
There is never a good time for COVID-related risks to be rising, but it is particularly unfortunate that the threat of renewed uncertainty and restrictions on economic activity has coincided with an apparent inflexion point in the messages from the UK money sector.
Not what the doctor ordered in either a literal or metaphorical sense.
Not what the doctor ordered
The rise in COVID-19 cases and the discovery of the new Omicron variant come at a delicate and unfortunate time for the UK economic recovery and associated recovery trades.
The number of people who tested positive has risen to 42, 583 according to the latest data provided on 29 November 2021. This represents an increase of 4,574 cases (12%) since the end of October 2021 (see chart above). In response to the identification of the new variant, the UK government has tightened restrictions on face coverings and entry into the UK. The booster programme for vaccines has also been accelerated. It remains too early to know if further restrictions will be required.
Why the timing is so bad
According to the Bank of England’s latest “Money and Credit” release for October 2021, monthly household money flows slowed sharply at the start of 4Q21.
These flows represent a useful proxy for household uncertainty. They peaked at £28bn (6x pre-pandemic levels) in May 2020 and again at £21bn (4x pre-pandemic levels) in December 2020. Note that money flows combine forced and precautionary elements of household savings. During periods of “lockdown” (see black bars in chart above), they averaged 4x their pre-pandemic levels reflecting the added impact of forced savings. Between lockdowns and since lockdowns they have averaged 2x their pre-pandemic levels.
Monthly flows fell from £9bn (2x pre-pandemic levels) in September 2021 to £5bn (1.2x pre-pandemic levels) in October 2021, the lowest monthly flow since February 2020.
UK households borrowed £0.7bn in consumer credit in October 2021, the strongest net borrowing since July 2020 (see chart above). Monthly flows have been positive since April 2021 – seven consecutive months of positive net borrowing. The majority of this borrowing (£0.6bn) was additional borrowing on credit cards, which was also the strongest since July 2020 (£0.9bn).
The annual growth rate in consumer credit remains negative, however (green line in chart above). That said, the YoY growth rate has narrowed to -1.0% in October from -1.7% in September and the low of -9.1% in January 2021.
So called “faster indicators” such as credit and debit card payments also indicate that these positive trends continued into mid-November 2021. After a sharp recovery in payments in March and April 2021 (following the easing of restrictions) momentum slowed in 2Q21 and 3Q21. Aggregate card payments rebounded in November, however, to reach 103% of pre-pandemic levels (see chart above).
Spending on “delayable” goods such as clothing and furniture has also recovered to 104% of pre-pandemic levels during November. This matters because spending on delayable goods is a useful indicator regarding the extent to which the £160bn in excess savings built up during the pandemic is returning to the economy via household consumption. The evidence to date is that while the build up of excess savings has slowed, this cash has yet to be spent (see chart above). A positive note to carry into the new year.
Conclusion
There is never a good time for COVID-related risks to be rising, but it is particularly unfortunate that the threat of renewed uncertainty and restrictions on economic activity has coincided with an apparent inflexion point in the messages from the UK money sector. Not what the doctor ordered in either a literal or metaphorical sense.
Please note that the summary comments and charts above are extracts from more detailed analysis that is available separately.