The key chart
The key message
Following recent analysis of global and emerging market (EM) debt dynamics and in advance of the Indian government’s announcement of its annual budget on 1 February 2022, this post summarises seven key structural features of Indian debt dynamics.
India is the third largest EM debt market in terms of total, private sector (PSC), corporate (NFC), and household (HH) debt after China and Korea and ahead of Brazil and Russia. Beyond absolute size, the key features of Indian debt dynamics include:
- PSC accounts for a relatively low share (51%) of total debt. In this context, India ranks #15 among our sample of 21 EM economies
- In terms of the private versus public sector breakdown, India is similar to Brazil but very different to Russia, Korea and China
- This matters because risks associated with elevated private sector debt are greater than those associated with public sector debt
- While Indian debt markets are large in absolute terms, the level of indebtedness is relatively low. Both the NFC (55% GDP) and HH (36% GDP) debt ratios are below both EM averages and BIS threshold limits
- Indian debt ratios are also relatively low in an historic context. HH indebtedness peaked at 43% GDP in 3Q07 while NFC indebtedness peaked at 71% GDP in 4Q12 (n.b. debt levels and levels of indebtedness are very different measures!)
- India has experienced periods of elevated risks associated with excess credit growth in the (not-so-distant) past – first in the NFC sector (until 4Q14) and then in the HH sector (since 3Q19). Current risks are moderate, however, in both sectors with RGFs below recent peaks
- Affordability risks in India are also relatively low in EM, global and historic contexts. India’s PS debt service ratio of 10% is well below its 10Y average of 13%
These features re-enforce the conclusion of “Global Debt Dynamics – V” that it is time to “replace the EM debt story with individual EM country debt stories.” Debt dynamics and their implications for policy, investment decisions and financial stability differ markedly even among EM’s five largest markets.
In short, India scores relatively well in terms of the risks associated with structure, indebtedness, growth and affordability of debt.
The India debt story
Size
India is the third largest EM debt market in terms of total ($4,656bn), PSC ($2,550bn), NFC (£1,540bn) and HH debt ($1,011bn) after China and Korea and ahead of Brazil and Russia (see chart above).
Structure
A key feature of the structure of Indian debt is the relatively low share of private sector debt (51% total). In this context, India ranks #15 among the 21 BIS EM reporting economies. In other words, the private versus public sector breakdown of India debt is similar to Brazil but very different to Russia, Korea, and China (see chart above).
This matters because risks associated with elevated private sector debt are greater than those associated with elevated public sector debt.
Indebtedness
While India is a large debt market in absolute terms, the level of indebtedness is relatively low in an EM context (see above). In terms of PSC (90% GDP), NFC (55% GDP) and HH (36% GDP) debt ratios, India ranks #11, #12, and #10 respectively. Both the NFC and HH debt ratios are below the EM averages (dotted blue line) and the BIS threshold limits (dotted red line).
Indian debt ratios are also relatively low in an historic context. The HH debt ratio of 36% GDP is 7ppt below the 43% GDP peak reached back in 3Q07. The NFC debt ratio of 55% GDP is 16ppt below the 71% GDP peak reached in 4Q12, the point at which the PSC debt ratio also peaked at 106% GDP (see graph above).
NFC snapshot
At the end of 2Q21, the level of outstanding NFC debt was $1,540bn, $39bn below the peak level recorded in the previous quarter. As noted above, India is the third largest NFC debt market in absolute terms with a market share of 4%. In terms of NFC indebtedness, however, India ranks #12 among the EM universe. NFC’s share of total debt (31%) is also relatively low. In this context, India ranks #14 among the EM universe.
HH snapshot
The level of outstanding HH debt was $1,010bn at the end of 2Q21, again £26bn below the peak level recorded in the previous sector. India is the third largest HH debt market in our EM universe with a market share of 6%. In terms of indebtedness, however, India ranks #10 among our EM universe. HH debt represents a relatively low 20% of total debt. In this context, India ranks #12 among our EM universe. In other words, the HH and NFC sectors share a number of similar characteristics.
Excess credit growth
In terms of risks to macro policy, investment decisions and financial stability, the lesson from EM history is that the rate of excess credit growth can be as important as the level of indebtedness.
The risks associated with excess credit growth in India are relatively low in an EM context (see chart) above and in an historic context. The latest PSC RGF of 1.8% is lower than the EM average of 6.0% and the levels for China (2.3%), Korea (5.8%), Brazil (6.2%) and Russia (2.2%), countries with higher of similar (Brazil) PSC debt ratios.
In the post-GFC period, India has experienced periods of elevate growth risks, first in the NFC sector and then in the HH sector. Over the past five years, these risks have been concentrated in the HH sector but rose more recently in the NFC sector again (see chart above). Note however, the rates of excess growth rates have peaked in both cases (and remain modest in absolute terms).
Affordability
Affordability risks in India are also relatively low in an EM and global context and in an historic Indian context. The chart above plots the latest debt service ratios (DSR) for BIS reporting economies (x-axis) and the deviation of each DSR from its LT average. As can be seen India has a relatively low DSR of 9.8%, well below its 10-year average of 12.5% (see also chart below).
Conclusion
These features re-enforce the conclusion of “Global Debt Dynamics – V” that it is time to “replace the EM debt story with individual EM country debt stories.”
Debt dynamics and their implications for policy, investment decisions and financial stability differ markedly even among EM’s five largest markets, for example (see the summary heatmap above).
In short, India scores relatively well in terms of risks associated with structure, indebtedness, growth and affordability of debt (n.b. the lack of red shading in the heatmap above in relation to India).
Please note that the summary comments and charts above are extracts from more detailed analysis that is available separately.