The key chart
The key message
UK and euro area (EA) money sectors have sent remarkably consistent messages throughout the COVID-pandemic. Shared trends in monetary aggregates, for example, provided similar conclusions regarding household (HH) behaviour, consumption and growth, the challenges facing policy makers, and the productivity of lending to the private sector (PSC).
The 4Q21 proved to be an important inflexion point in terms of HH confidence and behaviour in both regions. By December 2021, monthly deposit flows had moderated to 0.6x and 0.7x their pre-pandemic levels in the UK and EA respectively, leaving excess savings of c£162bn and c€285bn in the form of bank deposits. Demand for consumer credit recovered to 1.4% YoY and 1.2% YoY in the UK and EA respectively, and quarterly flows were positive in each of the past three quarters. So far, so good.
In addition to rising inflation, the Bank of England and the ECB both face on-going challenges in terms of the persistent desychronisation of money and credit cycles, which limits monetary policy effectiveness, and the fact that policy responses to date have fuelled growth in the wrong type of credit. The gap between the growth in money supply (ST liabilities of banks) and growth in PSC (key assets of banks) has narrowed but remains wide by historic standards. Nonetheless, the build-up of excess liquidity in both regions is slowing. Mortgage lending, the largest element of so-called “FIRE-based” lending, continues to be the main driver of PSC in the UK and the EA. This has potentially negative implications for growth, leverage, income inequality and financial stability.
In short, the money sectors in the UK and EA continue to sing from the same song sheet. The message for corporates, policy makers and investors alike is that an important inflexion point was reached in terms of HH confidence and behaviour in 4Q21. This is welcome news.
Of course, policy challenges remain and a slowdown in excess liquidity and/or a diversion into productive COCO-based lending rather than less productive FIRE-based lending may be less welcome news for financial assets in 2022.
Singing from the same song sheet
The money sectors in the UK and the euro area (EA) have sent remarkably consistent messages throughout the COVID-19 pandemic. We know that narrow money (M1), and overnight deposits within M1, drove the expansion of broad money (M4ex, M3 respectively) in both regions during 2020, for example. In other words, the rise in broad money illustrated in the chart above was a reflection of the deflationary forces of increased savings and delayed consumption.
We also know that, as at the end of December 2021, M1 represented 68% and 73% of M3 in the UK and the EA, up from 48% and 51% respectively a decade earlier (see chart below). Preference for highly liquid assets remains high, despite the negative real returns earned from those assets.
A sustained recovery in both regions required/requires a reversal of these deflationary trends ie, a moderation in monthly HH deposit flows and a recovery in consumer credit (see “Three key charts for 2021”). Central banks also need to see a resynching of money and credit cycles. Why? Because, monetary policy effectiveness is based on certain stable relationships between monetary aggregates.
As noted in “Missing the point?” in December 2021, HH behaviour reached a potentially important inflexion point at the start of the 4Q21. Monthly deposit flows (see chart above) peaked at 5.9x pre-pandemic levels in the UK in May 2020 and 2.4x pre-pandemic levels in the EA in April 2020. In December 2021, these flows had moderated to 0.6x and 0.7x pre-pandemic levels respectively. During this process HHs have accumulated excess savings in the form of bank deposits of £162bn in the UK and €285bn in the EA (CMMP estimates).
Annual growth rates in consumer credit reached a low point in February 2021 in both the UK (-10% YoY) and the EA (-3% YoY). In December 2021, however, annual growth rates had recovered to 1.4% YoY and 1.2% YoY respectively in the UK and EA respectively (see chart above). More importantly perhaps, quarterly flows of consumer credit have been positive and rising for the past three quarters (see chart below). The 4Q21 flows of £3bn and €4bn in the UK and EA respectively remain below pre-pandemic levels, however, especially in the EA where quarterly flows averaged €10bn during 2018-2019.
The COVID-19 pandemic exacerbated the desynchronisation of money and credit cycles in the UK and EA creating major challenges for policy makers, banks and investors alike. The degree of this desynchronisation peaked in early 2021 and reached its narrowest level since early 2020 in December 2021 (see chart below). That said, the gap between the growth rates of money supply (short-term liabilities of banks) and private sector lending (the main asset of banks) persists and remains high in a historic context.
Mortgage lending, the largest element of so-called “FIRE-based lending”, continues to be the main driver of PSC growth in both regions (see chart below). In December 2021, mortgage lending grew 5.1% YoY in the UK and 5.4% YoY in the EA. Lending to NFCs, the largest element of more productive “COCO-based lending”, rose 4.2% YoY in the EA but fell -0.4% YoY in the UK. As described above, consumer credit, another form of COCO-based lending grew 1.4% YoY and 1.2% YoY in the UK and EA respectively.
Conclusion
The money sectors in the UK and EA continue to sing from the same song sheet. The message for corporates, policy makers and investors alike is that an important inflexion point was reached in terms of HH confidence and behaviour in 4Q21. This is welcome news. Of course, policy challenges remain and a slowdown in excess liquidity and/or a diversion into productive COCO-based lending rather than less productive FIRE-based lending may be less welcome news for financial assets in 2022.
Please note that the summary comments and charts above are extracts from more detailed analysis that is available separately.