The key chart
The key message
Trends in monetary aggregates provide important insights into the interaction between the money sector and the wider economy. Headline growth figures can easily be misinterpreted, however, leading to false narratives regarding their implications for investment decisions and asset allocation.
To avoid this, CMPP analysis has identified three key signals that help to interpret current trends in the UK and euro area (EA) effectively: monthly household (HH) deposit flows (behaviour); the synchronisation of money and credit cycles (policy context); and consumer credit (growth outlook).
The UK and EA money sectors have provided consistent, if subdued, messages regarding HH behaviour, the policy context and the consumption/growth outlook during 1Q21:
- HHs in the UK and EA continue to increase their money holdings at very elevated rates, despite earning negative returns. Such behaviour contributes to neither growth nor inflation – a challenge for inflation hawks
- The unprecedented desynchronization of money and credit cycles continues to limit monetary policy effectiveness
- HHs are still repaying consumer credit and YoY growth rates hit historic lows during 1Q21
Investment narratives, like endurance athletes, require consistent refuelling to maintain performance. The best returns from equities are typically when economies are still weak but the rate of growth is either inflecting upwards or looking less weak. If such trends are accompanied by rising bond yields then cyclical sectors/stocks will typically outperform defensive sector/stocks (Oppenheimer, 2020).
The key messages from the money sectors (summarised above) have provided only limited nourishment for those positioned for sustained inflation and/or cyclical recovery in the UK and EA to date.
March data provided tentative encouragement in terms of the direction of travel but more substantive support may be required in 2Q21 to sustain recent performance.
Rather than focusing on headline growth numbers in broad money, investors should look instead for a more noticeable moderation in HH deposit flows, a resynchronisation in money and credit cycles and a recovery in consumer credit over the coming months.
Making sense of monetary aggregates
The CMMP approach
Trends in monetary aggregates provide important insights into the interaction between the money sector (central banks, FIs and NBFIs) and the wider economy. Headline YoY growth figures can easily be misinterpreted, however, leading to false narratives regarding their implications for investment decisions and asset allocation.
To avoid this, CMPP analysis has identified three key signals that help to interpret current trends in the UK and EA effectively: monthly HH deposit flows (behaviour); the synchronisation of money and credit cycles (policy context); and consumer credit (growth outlook).
A review of 1Q21
The UK and EA money sectors have provided consistent, if subdued, messages regarding household (HH) behaviour, policy effectiveness and the consumption/growth outlook during 1Q21.
HHs in the UK and EA continue to increase their money holdings at elevated rates, despite earning negative returns. UK and EA monthly flows of HH deposits are still 3.5x and 1.9x the levels seen in the pre-COVID periods. These latest data points for March 2021 are below the respective peaks of 5.8x (May 2020) and 2.4x (March 2020) for the UK and EA respectively. Nonetheless, they show that HHs are still preferring to hold highly liquid assets (overnight deposits), despite earning negative real returns.
High levels of precautionary and forced savings indicate that HH uncertainty remains elevated and consumption delayed (see below). The challenge here for inflation hawks is that money sitting idly in overnight deposits contributes to neither GDP growth nor inflation.
The unprecedented desynchronization of money and credit cycles continues to limit monetary policy effectiveness. The gap between YoY growth rates in private sector lending and money supply hit historic highs of 11.4ppt in the UK in February and 8.0ppt in the EA in January. This matters because the effectiveness of monetary policy relies, in part, on certain stable relationships between monetary aggregates.
The latest data for March 2021, indicates that the gaps have narrowed slightly to 10.8ppt in the UK and 6.5ppt in the EA. Again, inflation hawks will be disappointed, however, by the slowdown in the growth rates in private sector credit. In the UK, this fell from 3.9% YoY in February to only 1.5% YoY in March and in the EA, from 4.5% YoY in February to 3.6% in March.
HHs are still repaying consumer credit and YoY growth rates hit historic lows during 1Q21. In the UK, HHs have repaid consumer credit for seven consecutive months. In the EA, they have repaid consumer credit in five of the past seven months.
In both regions, the YoY growth rate hit a historic low in February of -10.0% in the UK and -2.8% in the EA before. In March the rate of decline slowed to -8.6% and -1.7% in the UK and EA respectively.
Investment implications
Investment narratives, like endurance athletes, require consistent refuelling to maintain performance. The best returns from equities are typically when economies are still weak but the rate of growth is either inflecting upwards or looking less weak. If such trends are accompanied by rising bond yields then cyclical sectors/stocks will typically outperform defensive sector/stocks (Oppenheimer, 2020). The key messages from the money sectors (summarised above) have provided only limited nourishment for those positioned for sustained inflation and/or cyclical recovery in the UK and EA in 2021 to date.
What to watch for in 2Q21
March data provided tentative encouragement in terms of the direction of travel but more substantive support may be required in 2Q21 to sustain recent performance. Rather than focusing on headline growth numbers in broad money, investors should look instead for a more noticeable moderation in HH deposit flows, a resynchronisation in money and credit cycles and a recovery in consumer credit over the coming months.
Please note that the summary comments and charts above are extracts from more detailed analysis that is available separately.