The key chart
The key message
Monthly mortgage flows suggest that Spain is re-joining the “euro area mortgage party” but this presents mixed messages for investors.
Spain remains the euro area’s (EA) third largest mortgage market despite the fact that the outstanding stock of mortgages (€510bn) is 23% below its December 2010 peak (€665bn). Spain’s market share has fallen from 19% of EA mortgages in December 2008 to 11% in June 2021 and Spanish MFIs have recorded 120 consecutive months of negative contributions to EA mortgage growth since April 2011.
Monthly mortgage flows turned positive in February 2021, however. Annual growth rates turned positive in May 2021 and Spanish MFIs made a positive, albeit small, contribution to total EA growth in June 2021. I highlighted four factors that suggested a more positive demand-side outlook two months ago (see “More consistent than Rapha”). First, the HH debt ratio has fallen back in line with EA averages following a decade of deleveraging. Second, the cost of borrowing is at a record low. Third, the HH debt service ratio is below the LT average and close to its 20-year low. Finally, Spanish house prices are 28% below their peak in real terms with less extreme valuations than elsewhere in the EA.
The latest dynamics present mixed messages for investors. On the bright side, a sustained positive contribution to EA growth represents an important signal for investors positioned for a wider recovery in Europe. Germany and France have been the main drivers of mortgage growth in the recent past, but demand is now widening with Belgium, the Netherlands, Italy, Austria and Spain making larger collective contributions.
That said, these trends also reflect the broader substitution of productive COCO-based lending with less-productive FIRE-based lending in the euro area, which has negative implications for leverage, growth, financial stability and income inequality in the region. Spain has seen the largest shift in percentage points from COCO-based to FIRE-based lending since January 2009 but uniquely this reflects falls in the outstanding stock of both COCO-based (-€488bn) and FIRE-based lending (-€125bn) over the period.
The underlying message here is that mortgage dynamics in the periphery of the EA remain very different from those in the core re-enforcing the message that a “one-size-fits-all” policy response will not suffice.
“Bienvenido de nuevo” in charts
Please note that the summary comments and charts above are extracts from more detailed analysis that is available separately.