The key chart
The key message
Money and credit cycles have been desynchronised for much of the past decade, creating major challenges for policy makers, banks and investors alike.
Growth in money supply has also exceeded growth in private sector credit in the euro area and for much of the period in the UK. The effectiveness of monetary policy, the dominant macro policy, has diminished dramatically as a result.
The gap between growth in money supply and private sector credit hit a historic high during the COVID-19 pandemic. More recently, however, these growth rates have converged as the build-up of excess savings has slowed and the demand for credit has recovered (at least in nominal terms).
This means that three key signals from the UK and EA money sectors have turned more positive: monthly HH money flows have fallen back below pre-pandemic levels; quarterly consumer credit flows have been positive since 2Q21 and have returned to pre-pandemic levels in the UK; and the gap between money supply and private sector credit growth has narrowed.
Macro challenges remain, but the message from the UK and EA money sectors is less bearish than consensus investment narratives.
A desynchronised decade
Money and credit cycles have been desynchronised for much of the past decade. In typical cycles, monetary aggregates and their key counterparties, such as private sector credit, move together. Put simply, money supply indicates how much money is available for use by the private sector. Private sector credit indicates how much the private sector is borrowing. However, the two charts above show the extent to which, and the periods when, UK and EA money and credit cycles have diverged since March 2012.
Growth in money supply has also exceeded growth in private sector credit in the euro area and for much of the period in the UK. The charts above (EA) and below (UK) illustrate trends in the gap between money and credit flows (rolling quarters) for both regions. The build-up of liquidity in both regions is clear to see. Increases in the supply of money have not been matched by equivalent increases in private sector demand for credit.
The effectiveness of monetary policy, the dominant macro policy, has diminished dramatically as a result. Broadly speaking, monetary policy is effective if “central bank accommodation increase money and credit for the private sector to use” (Koo, 2015). Not only has credit growth lagged money supply growth, it has also been predominantly the “wrong type of credit” ie, less productive FIRE-based lending. As noted in previous posts, this has hidden risks in terms of leverage, future growth, financial stability and income inequality.
The gaps between growth in money supply and private sector credit hit historic highs during the COVID-19 pandemic (see chart above). In the UK, loan growth exceeded money growth between August 2018 and December 2019. During the pandemic, however, the gap between money growth (15.4%) and credit growth (3.9%) widened to 11.5ppt in February 2021. In the EA, money growth (4.9%) exceeded credit growth (3.7%) by 1.2ppt at the end of 2019. The gap peaked at 8ppt in January 2021 – money growth of 12.5% versus credit growth of 4.5%.
More recently, these growth rates have converged as the build-up of excess savings has slowed and credit demand has recovered (at least in nominal terms). At the end of 1Q22, money growth had slowed to 5.5% YoY in the UK while credit growth had risen to 3.7% YoY, a narrowing of the gap to only 1.8ppt. Similarly, in the EA, money growth at the end of 1Q22 had slowed to 6.3% YoY while credit growth was 4.7% YoY, a gap of 1.6ppt (see chart above).
Conclusion
What does this mean? Three key signals from the UK and EA money sectors have turned more positive: monthly HH money flows have fallen back below pre-pandemic levels; quarterly consumer credit flows have been positive since 2Q21 and have returned to pre-pandemic levels in the UK; and the gap between money supply and private sector credit growth has narrowed.
Macro challenges remain, but the message from the UK and EA money sectors is less bearish than consensus investment narratives.
Please note that the summary comments and charts above are extracts from more detailed analysis that is available separately.