“Fading recession risks?”

The key chart

The message from October’s data

Monetary indicators continue to move away from levels associated with recession risks in the Euro Area.

Narrow money (M1) grew 8.4% in nominal terms in October, up from 7.9% in September. In real terms, M1 grew 7.6% which is the fastest rate of real growth since October 2017 (8.0%) and compares with a real growth rate of only 4.7% in January this year. Given the leading indicator qualities of trends in real M1, this data supports the narrative that recession fears in the Euro Area have been overdone.

Households and corporates are also increasing their borrowing at the fastest rates in the current cycle. HH credit (a co-incident indicator) grew 3.5% in nominal terms and 2.8% in real terms, the fastest rate of real growth since April 2008. NFC credit (a lagging indicator) grew at 3.8% in nominal terms and 3.1% in real terms. The real growth was marginally below the level of 3.2% recorded in August 2019, but again these rates are the highest real growth rates since June 2009.

Of course, credit growth remains relative subdued in relation to LT trends and concentrated geographically (HH in France, Germany, Benelux and Italy; NFC is France, Germany and Austria) and the demand for credit continues to lag the supply of money which indicates that the Euro Area has still to recover fully from the debt overhang (see graph below).

A simple conclusion

Nonetheless, the message from October is simple: current monetary trends remain inconsistent with recession fears in the Euro Area

Please note that the summary comments above are abstracts from more detailed analysis that is available separately