“Debt dynamics in the developed world”

The key chart

Summary

The developed world continues to deleverage. This process has already led to dramatic shift in the structure of global private sector debt (see “The Changing Face of Global Debt”). With private sector debt levels still “too high” in the developed world, this trend is set to continue.

Risks associated with excess credit growth in the developed world are lower than in past cycles and remain concentrated by economy (Sweden, Switzerland, Canada and France) and by sector (NFC credit more than HH credit). Despite lower borrowing costs, affordability risks are still evident is both the NFC (Canada, France) and HH sectors (Norway, Canada, and Sweden).

Progress in dealing with the debt overhang in the Euro Area remains slow and incomplete. Long term secular challenges of subdued GDP, money supply and credit growth persist while unorthodox monetary policy measures risk fuelling further demand for less-productive “FIRE-based” lending with negative implications or leverage, growth, stability and income inequality (see “ Fuelling the FIRE” – the hidden risk in QE).

Trends in DM debt ratios

The developed world continues to deleverage. Private sector credit as a percentage of GDP has fallen from a peak of 181% in 3Q09 to 162% at the end of the 1Q19. This has involved a (relatively gradual) process of “passive deleveraging” where the stock of outstanding debt rises but at a slower rate than nominal GDP.

The process of deleveraging in the Euro Area started later. Private sector credit as a percentage of GDP peaked at 172% in 1Q15 and has fallen to 162% at the end of 1Q19, in-line with the average for the BIS’ sample of advanced economies.

This process has led to a dramatic shift in the structure of global debt. In 1Q00, the advanced world accounted for 90% of global private sector credit, with advanced economies excluding the Euro Area accounting for 70% and the Euro Area 20%. Emerging markets accounted for only 10% of global private sector credit with 7% from emerging markets excluding China and 3% from China.

At the end of 1Q19, the advanced world’s share of global debt had fallen to 64% (advanced economies ex Euro Area 47%, Euro Area 18%) while the emerging markets share has increased to 36% (EM ex China 12%, China 24%).

Where are we now?

With debt levels remaining “too high” in the advanced world this trend is likely to continue. The BIS considers corporate (NFC) and household (HH) debt ratios of 90% and 85% respectively to be maximum thresholds above which debt becomes a constraint on future growth.

In our sample of advanced economies, only Greece, Germany, Italy, Austria and the US have debt ratios below these thresholds in both sectors. In contrast both NFC and HH debt levels are above the BIS thresholds in the Netherlands, Sweden, Norway, Switzerland, Denmark and Canada. NFC debt ratios remain above the threshold in Ireland, Belgium, France, Portugal and Spain and while the UK has “excess” HH debt. In short, progress towards dealing with high levels of private sector debt remains incomplete.

Associated risks

Private sector growth risks

Risks associated with “excess credit growth” in developed markets are lower than in past cycles. I introduced my Relative Growth Factor analysis in “Sustainable debt dynamics – Asia private sector credit”. In short, this simple framework compares the relative growth in credit versus GDP (3 year CAGR) with the level of debt penetration in a given economy.

In terms of total private sector debt, the highest “growth risks” can be seen in Sweden, Switzerland, Canada and France. Private sector credit in each of these economies has outstripped GDP growth on a CAGR basis over the past three years despite relatively high levels of private sector debt. Canada has made the most obvious adjustment among this sample of relatively high risk economies with the RGF falling from over 4% two years ago to 1.8% currently.

NFC sector growth risks

In the NFC sector, the highest risks can be observed in Switzerland, Sweden, Canada and France. RGFs for these for these economies were 3.9%, 3.0%, 2.7% and 1.8% respectively, despite NFC debt levels that are well above the BIS threshold. As above, Canada’s rate of excess NFC credit growth is slowing in contrast to trends in Switzerland and Sweden.

HH sector growth risks

In the HH sector, RGF analysis suggest that the highest risks are in Norway, Switzerland, Canada, Norway (and the UK). RGFs in these economies were 1.3%, 1.1%, 0.7% and 0.4% respectively. In other words, excess HH credit growth risk is lower than in the NFC sector. Furthermore, the rates of excess HH credit growth in each of these economies is lower than in the recent past, especially in Norway and Canada.

Affordability risks

Despite lower borrowing costs, affordability risks remain. BIS debt service ratios (DSR) provide, “important information about the interactions between debt and the real economy, as they measure the amount of income used for interest payments and amortisations.” (BIS, 2017). The perspective provided by DSRs complements the analysis of debt ratios above but differs in the sense that they provide a “flow-to-flow” comparison ie, the debt service payments divided by the flow of income. In the accompanying charts, DSR ratios for private sector, corporate and household credit are plotted against the deviation from their respective long term averages.  

NFC affordability risks are highest in Canada and France. Debt service ratios (57% and 55% respectively) are not only high in absolute terms but they also illustrate the highest deviations from their respective long-term averages (47% and 49% respectively). In the HH sector, the highest affordability risks are seen in Norway, Canada and Sweden, although the level of risk is lower than in the NFC sector.

Implications for the Euro Area

Progress in dealing with the debt overhang in the Euro Area remains slow and incomplete. Long term secular challenges of subdued GDP, money supply and credit growth persist. The European Commission recently revised its 2019 forecast down by -0.1ppt to 1.1% and its 2020 and 2012 forecasts down by -0.2ppt to 1.2% in both years, with these forecasts relying on “the strength of more domestically-oriented sectors.

Growth in broad money (5.5%) and private sector credit (3.7%) in September remains positive in relation to recent trends but relative subdued in relation to past cycles. Furthermore, the renewed widening in the gap between the growth in the supply of money and the demand from credit (-1.8%) indicates that the Euro Area continues to face the challenge of deficiency in the demand for credit.

This has on-going implications for policy choices.  Unorthodox monetary policy measures risk fuelling further demand for less-productive “FIRE-based” lending with negative implications or leverage, growth, stability and income inequality (see “ Fuelling the FIRE” – the hidden risk in QE).

Please note that the summary comments above are abstracts from more detailed analysis that is available separately.