The key chart
The key message
July’s monetary developments in the euro area suggest that the road to recovery will be long and uncertain. Broad money (M3) is growing at the fastest rate (10.2% YoY) since May 2008. Growth rates in the components of M3 indicate that uncertainty remains very elevated at the start of 3Q20. Overnight deposits, for example, contributed 8.3ppt to the growth in broad money alone (despite negative real returns). July’s overnight deposit inflow of €151bn was the second largest inflow after March’s €249bn and was 3x the 2019 average. In contrast, growth rates in the counterparts to M3 indicate that HH consumption is recovering and the NFC’s record “dash-for-cash” has peaked. However, before anyone gets too excited – the gap between subdued PSC growth (debt overhang?) and rapid M3 growth (elevated uncertainty?) hit a twenty-year peak in July.
In short, July’s message from the EA money sector is simple: the peak of the crisis may have passed but the road to recovery is likely to be long and uncertain.
The long and uncertain road in charts
July’s monetary developments in the euro area (EA) suggest that the road to recovery will be a long and uncertain one. Broad money (M3) grew by 10.2% YoY in July from 9.2% in June, the fastest rate of growth since May 2008.
Narrow money (M1) grew by 13.5% YoY in July from 12.6% in June, faster than the 13.1% (Aug 09) and 11.7% (July 15) peak growth rates recorded during the GFC and after the euro crisis. M1 growth contributed 9.2ppt to the total 10.2% growth in broad money. Within M1, overnight deposits grew 14.1% YoY and contributed 8.3ppt to the overall growth in M3 alone.
Adjusted loans to the private sector grew 4.7% YoY, slightly below the 4.8% recorded in June. The annual growth rate in loans to households (HHs) was unchanged at 3.0% while the equivalent growth rate in loans to corporates (NFCs) fell very slightly to 7.0% from 7.1%. No surprises here – above trend NFC credit and resilient HH mortgage demand continue to offset weakness in HH consumer credit.
The gap between the growth in money supply (M3) and the growth in private sector credit (PSC) increased to 5.5ppt, a twenty year high. This reflects the combination of extraordinary uncertainty (driving M3) and the limited progress in dealing with the debt overhang in the EA (subduing PSC).
The monthly flow data once again provides a more nuanced picture than the headline annual growth trends. Overnight deposits, which contributed 8.3ppt to the overall growth in M3 alone, rose by €151b. This represents the second largest monthly inflow of overnight deposits (after €249bn in March 2020).
July’s data includes a €58bn swing from negative to positive flows from non-monetary financial corporations – n.b. these flows are typically more volatile than HH and NFC flows. That said, monthly flows by HHs and NFCs also increased MoM to levels 24% and almost 50% above the average 2019 inflows. Put simply, these trends suggest that HH and NFC uncertainty levels remain very elevated.
On a more positive note, mortgage demand remains resilient and consumer credit has recovered. Loans for house purchase increased by €19b in July versus 9€10bn in June and above the average €14bn monthly flow recorded in 2019. After record repayments between March and May 2020, monthly flows of credit for consumption have exceeded €3bn for two months in a row, closing on the €3.4bn monthly average in 2019. NFC lending data suggests that we passed the peak “dash for cash” in March and April, although July’s monthly flow of almost €16bn remains above the 2019 average of €12bn.
Conclusion
The message from the money sector at the start of the 3Q20 is a mixed one. Growth rates in the components of M3 indicate that uncertainty remains very elevated. In contrast, growth rates in the counterparts to M3 indicated that HH consumption is recovering and the NFC dash-for-cash has peaked. In short, while the peak of the crisis appears to have passed, the road to road to recovery is likely to remain a long and uncertain one.
Please note that the summary comments and graphs above are extracts from more detailed analysis that is available separately.